Wednesday, August 31, 2016


The Hockey News released its ranking of the Top 50 players in the NHL as part of their 2016-17 Yearbook. Here are the top ten:

1. Sidney Crosby - Penguins C

2. Patrick Kane - Blackhawks RW

3. Carey Price - Canadiens G

4. Jamie Benn - Stars LW

5. Jonathan Toews - Blackhawks C

6. Drew Doughty - Kings D

7. Anze Kopitar - Kings C

8. Erik Karlsson - Senators D

9. Connor McDavid - Oilers C

10. Joe Pavelski - Sharks C

Notice anyone missing? Like...I dunno...the second biggest superstar in the sport?

Alex Ovechkin was ranked 11th

If you're not a hockey fan then allow me to compare it thusly: would you have a top ten list of MLB superstars without Bryce Harper? A top ten list of NBA players without Stephen Curry? Of course not. So why did The Hockey News rank Ovi so low?

Maybe it's because he doesn't play defense? Please. Show me Patrick Kane's Selke trophy (or for that matter, Sidney Crosby's.)

Maybe it's because Ovechkin has yet to win a Stanley Cup. Remind me again how many rings Carey Price has?

Connor McDavid is going to be a superstar someday. Perhaps even next year. But he's played one half of one season in the NHL. Who wrote this list, Don Cherry?

I'd have Connor much higher, eh. Good Canadian boy!

Last time I checked, the object of the game is to put the puck in the net. No one has done that more frequently over the last year, or the last five years, or the last ten years than Alexander the Great. He's entering his age 31 season and has already built a Hall Of Fame career. (sound familiar?)

Here's my top ten list, in case you were wondering:

1. Sidney Crosby - Penguins C

2. Patrick Kane - Blackhawks RW

I'm not convinced that Crosby is still the best player in the NHL - but no one has pulled ahead of him yet. Kane could pass him with another 100-point season this year.

3. Carey Price - Canadiens G  Jamie Benn - Stars LW

Benn or Ovechkin, take your pick. I don't believe that any goalie in the league is as dominant at preventing goals as Ovechkin is at scoring them. Look at it this way - if you were drafting a fantasy team and you could pick any goalie, who would you take: Price, Henrik Lundqvist, Braden Holtby or Jonathan Quick? Yeah... that's why there are no netminders in my top ten. (I'd probably punt on those guys and take Cory Schneider.)

4. Jamie Benn - Stars LW  Alex Ovechkin - Capitals LW

The absolute lowest he could possiby be ranked. Maybe 5th if you really want to argue.

Obviously everyone's list will be different. But if you don't have Crosby, Kane, and Ovechkin in your top five then you're just...wrong.

I may be a little biased here

5. Jonathan Toews - Blackhawks C  Erik Karlsson - Senators D

Toews, Kopitar, and Patrice Bergeron are all terrific two-way centermen (that's why they keep swapping the Selke.) But there is no one in the NHL like Erik Karlsson. Did you know he was tied for 4th in scoring last year? Not 4th among defensemen...4th in the league. When was the last time a defenseman did that? Karlsson has won two Norris Trophies already and nearly won a third last year. Oh, and he's entering his age-26 season. 

6. Drew Doughty - Kings D

Here's the guy that beat Karlsson for the Norris. I guess 6th place is fine. 

7. Anze Kopitar - Kings C  Steven Stamkos - Lightning C 

I'm a bit hesitant to put Kopi here since, again, you're splitting hairs between Bergy and Toews. Stamkos has been a goal-scoring machine when healthy, and I believe he'll score 50 goals again soon.

8. Erik Karlsson - Senators D  John Tavares - Islanders C

This is where it gets tricky for me. Kopitar or Toews would be fine here - and I wouldn't argue with Pavelski. But Tavares has to be on the list somewhere.

9. Connor McDavid - Oilers C  Joe Pavelski - Sharks C

Can't put Connor McDavid in the top 20, let alone top 10. Not when there's still no room for Toews, Kopitar, Bergeron, Evgeni Malkin, Tyler Seguin, Johnny Gaudreau, and many others. Pavelski and Jamie Benn have been underrated for too long - and to prove I'm not buying in to East Coast bias, I'm squeezing in one more Western Conference forward...

10. Joe Pavelski - Sharks C  Vladimir Tarasenko - Blues RW

So I like goal scorers. Sue me. Tarasenko was one of only four 40-goal scorers last year, and 7 of the NHL's top 8  are on my list (sorry, Brad Marchand.) He's entering his age 25 season and I don't think he's hit his peak yet. 

Who's my number 11, you ask? Good question! Probably Toews. Or Kopitar. Maybe Malkin if he's healthy. All I know is... it's not Alex Ovechkin. 


Tuesday, August 30, 2016


On the same day that my COMC order arrived in (the general vicinity of) my mailbox... my BGS order arrived in my COMC inventory.

It consisted of one card:

I submitted this two months ago, back when Mazara was a leading contender for AL Rookie of The Year. At the time, BGS 9 exampls of this card were selling on eBay for north of $250. Now they're about $150. Which is fine with me...I paid $32 ungraded so I've got no more than $50 into it. And I still have it. That is to say, I haven't sold it.

Tbh, I'm not sure if I want to sell it, keep it, or upgrade it. If I were to sell it I certainly wouldn't sell it now (unless I got impatient and/or saw something else I'd rather have - which has happened before.) And it might be tough to upgrade since there seem to be a lot of BGS 9's circulating and not a whole lot of 9.5's (I dont have a Beckett membership so I can't see the Pop report figures on this particular card). 

Plus it's always tough for me to upgrade a card I already own when I could buy a new card. I just sold ungraded Upper Deck rookie cards of Steven Stamkos and Taylor Hall so I could buy a BGS 9.5 Stamkos RC. Now I need another Taylor Hall - especially since he's now a New Jersey Devil. 

Mazara isn't the highest priority for me right now, and he's regressed to the mean over the summer, so I guess I'll just let it sit in my COMC "Not For Sale" queue until I can decide what to do with it.


Monday, August 29, 2016

COMC Mailday!

My latest order from Check Out My Cards arrived at my door this afternoon. I don't love their new shipping rates but it's understandable. What frustrates me is that they are taking longer to ship out orders.

When I started buying from COMC they would ship all the cards in their WA warehouse right away (usually within 2-5 business days) and if you ordered anything from their Canadian warehouse those would be shipped separately and arrive 2-3 weeks later. This probably cost them a lot of money and hassle, which is why they scrapped that. I have no issue with that, either.

But this order that arrived today contained zero cards from their Canadian warehouse. I requested shipment on Aug 13, and t should have arrived one week later..maybe ten days, tops. Instead I had to wait 16 days. And I paid an extra buck due to the price increase. Pay more, wait longer? Not cool, COMC.

Rant over. 

Here's a few scans of the cards I was waiting for. This is the first time in a while that I didn't buy any graded cards or higher-end singles. I think the most I paid for any one card was $12.50 - for the Martin Brodeur Hockey Heroes card at the top left:

all these are PC (the Ovie is a glossy parallel)

I really like the 2015-16 O-Pee-Chee Platinum set. Target had some packs but almost all of them were tampered with (lousy punk kids) so I bought a handful of singles instead. 

I love, Platinum

The regular O-Pee-Chee Update RCs were dirt cheap, thanks to Upper Deck ePack users flooding the site with singles:

Max Domi is underrated.

Some random stuff I picked up. The Exquisite/Immaculate base cards are really nice - and surprisingly affordable - and the Perry jersey was $0.75 (thanks again, ePack!)

I don't really collect much football anymore, but I needed this Brian Urlacher Finest rookie to finish off my set. Only took me 16 years!

Low-end Red Sox were a significant portion of this order. I got a pile o' Dustin Pedroia cards, and a few assorted Sawx - past, present, and (possibly) future.

Last but not least, I scored a few vintage singles. This 1955 Bowman Enos Slaughter was only $4.80:

The surface on this card is very clean and I can't find any creases. However I'm not sure if the card is miscut or just off-center. It wouldn't be the first time; I bought  a 1968 Topps Roberto Clemente and a 1975 Robin Yount RC from COMC that were badly miscut - and a pair of 1952 Topps commons (Eddie Yost and Sibby Sisti) that PSA returned as trimmed. 

Either way, it's a nice vintage card of a Hall Of Famer  for under $5. Can't complain.

And finally.. the newest additions to my 1956 Topps collection (I'm still hesitating to use the word "set") :

The Erskine and Maas were $7-8 each, and are very clean. I'll send those to PSA eventually. The Ray Moore (white back) is a little iffy. The corners are a bit softer than I'd like, and there seems to be a tiny crease at the top right. I don't have my microscope nearby so it looks more like a crack... but it's not horrible. And it was only $2.05. 

I'm up to 36 cards out of 340 from the 1956 Topps set, though I might sell three of the subpar singles in a vintage lot. 

Have you bought anything from COMC lately? What do you like/dislike about the site?


Saturday, August 27, 2016

Damn Yankees

A couple weeks ago I wrote on my "personal" blog about Yankees rookie slugger Aaron Judge and lamented that I sold his rookie card too soon - especially after he debuted with two homers in two games. Since then he's cooled off considerably - which pleases me as a seller and as a Red Sox fan.

However, I've now got seller's remorse over another record-breaking rookie, Gary Sanchez. 

I picked up this 2013 Bowman Sterling Prospects Japan Fractor Gary Sanchez card for $1.80 on COMC in early June with the intention of flipping it for a few extra bucks. 

What the heck is a 'Japan Fractor' anyway?

It took a lot longer than expected, as Sanchez was still in triple-A at the time. But a month later I sold the Sanchez card for $4.50. I don't want to know what it would sell for now. 

It's not a rookie year card of Sanchez and Bowman Chrome usually carries a bit more cache than Sterling. But still.. it's #d to 25, Sanchez is red-hot right now, and he's been talking (tweeting?) about leading the Yankees to the playoffs - which was unthinkable about a month ago.

The Yanks have been in need of a rebuild for years, and Brian Cashman finally pulled the trigger last month. You have to give him credit for the deadline deals he made and the prospects NY has brought in at the draft and the deadline. A lineup of Sanchez, Judge, Greg Bird, Clint Frazier, and whatever free agents they throw money at in the next few years is going to be deadly. 

But I thought we'd have at least a year or two to relax and enjoy the pennant and wild-card races sans Evil Empire, especially this year with the Red Sox doing all they can to give David Ortiz a proper postseason send-off. 

Sigh. I never thought I'd say this but... I miss A-Rod.

This is the crossover candidate I mentioned in my earlier post. Paid $74.65 on 4SC. 

[Hat tip to The Lost Collector who wrote about Gary Sanchez earlier today and is probably enjoying this a lot more than I am]  


Friday, August 26, 2016

Debtor Hall Of Shame

As I may have mentioned on my blog(s) I work part-time as a debt collector at a small law firm. I started out as a file clerk which made me a lot less money - and a lot less stressed out. Most of my day was spent collecting all the papers in the "file pile" and placing them in pockets. There are over 3,000 pocket file folders in our office and I became familiar with many of the names. If a person's name randomly pops into my head and I can't recall where I know them from, chances are they're a debtor. 

Now if you're a sports fanatic like me, you probably know the names of at least a thousand current and former athletes. So if you hear a common name like "Joe Smith" you might immediately think of this Joe Smith or that Joe Smith. But chances are the Joe Smith in question is ordinary Joe. As such, I never stopped to think that any of our debtors might be former athletes until I saw printed proof - a Wikipedia page of a former NBA lottery pick.  

I have to admit I was a lot more intrigued about this case than any of the 3,000 others. It made sense that this particular player would owe money to one of our clients, since he briefly played in New Jersey and was/is a journeyman player who couldn't cut it in the NBA (last I heard he was playing in China - waaaay out of our jurisdiction). 

But a few months later I came across another file folder that caught my curiosity. This was one of our oldest files (it was in the basement) and I hadn't seen any paperwork on it so I had to actually open the file and snoop around to see if it was the former NBA player I was thinking of. Sure enough, it was this guy. Unlike Mr. Williams, Mr. Long never played for the New Jersey Nets - but he was a color commentator for a different NBA team, so maybe he racked up some debts while working for the visitors. 

I guess they wanted to be like Mike

The third athlete on this list is not a former basketball player, and does not have a common surname. When I saw his file in our cabinet I was all but certain that it belonged to a former All-Star catcher for the Dodgers and Mets (no, it's not Mike Piazza.) Not only was this guy a deadbeat debtor, he was also listed on the Mitchell Report for alleged use of performance-enhancing drugs. Just an all-around swell guy.

As with Mr. Long's file, I pulled out all the paperwork I could before someone caught me snooping (no one did), and while I don't recall who he owed or how much, I did learn that he was also an announcer - but for horse racing. Ya think he could have racked up some gambling debts at the track?

I should tell you that I haven't seen an update on any of these debtor files since I started working in collections. It's possible that their debts have been paid, settled, or otherwise closed (I think that's the case for Mr. LoDuca.) 

Still, it has inspired a little subset in my collection - my own little "Debtor Hall of Shame" 

My boss once asked me - quite randomly - how I would rate my knowledge of the Eagles. I legit could not tell if he meant the rock group or the football team, but he mentioned something about a lineman or linebacker who had a debt with our client. I looked up the name but found nothing. Perhaps he paid it off before we were able to open a file on him.

I'll keep an eye out for any other former athletes who owe us money. If I catch one, I'll add it to the debt collection. (Get it? Debt collection. Haha...I'll show myself out.)


Update: it seems we have a fourth former pro athlete who has owed us money for quite some time (at least five years). I noticed this file sticking out of the 'pulled files' box, which means that one of the attorneys worked on it recently. I'm a bit surprised that there are still old files I have not seen before, but that was the case with this one - until now.

Mr. Becht, welcome to the the Debtor Hall of Shame!

Thursday, August 25, 2016

Am I Really Doing This? (1956 Topps edition)

My latest (and most expensive) order from 4 Sharp Corners arrived yesterday*. 

[*Eventually I'll organize these as "mailday posts" but I'm just getting started here so I've gotta clear all the brainsludge first.]

I had accumulated over $300 in PP cash from selling all my PSA-graded 1979 Topps Hall of Famers - including the Willie Stargell PSA 9 that I picked up for less than a buc. When I have that much cash to spend on cards, I like to buy a big piece.

What is a "big piece", you ask?

Think of it as a pie (or pie chart, if you prefer.) The amount of money you're spending is the pie. (In this case it's $400). Now, you can slice up that pie into an equal number of pieces (forty $10 pieces, or twenty $20 pieces, for example) 


You can do what I like to do - cut your pie into one big piece and a few small pieces. With this latest 4SC order I knew I wanted to take advantage of their discounted prices on common low-end singles for my 1984-85 O-Pee-Chee Hockey project but I wanted something meaty - either from 4SC or another source.

4SC's prices on high-end cards are rarely competitive, but I found two nice cards that were in my budget. The first was a 1994 SP Alex Rodriguez RC. 

I do not like A-Rod. But it was an SGC 96 (always thought they were SCG - that would make more sense, yes?) and I'm gonna try PSA's crossover service and hope for a MINT 9. The second card was my aforementioned big piece. 

My first priority when buying a "big piece" is always Baseball Hall Of Famers. I don't have a lot of money (I'm only a part-time debt collector) so my game plan is to buy the oldest card possible, in the best condition possible, of the best player possible.

That pretty much rules out first-tier legends like Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, and Ted Williams (though I do own one Willie and one Ted.) Andso I focus on the second-tier of baseball greats - HOFers like Frank Robinson, Harmon Killebrew, Bob Gibson... and Warren Spahn.

I paid just a tad over SMR value for this card, but I felt good about my purchase. This is one of about a dozen vintage cards in my $200 and over collection, and it has the added bonus of being a 1956 Topps card.

You see, when I was a young lad, my mom often bought me sports cards as Christmas gifts. I remember receiving countless packs in my stocking, and hobby boxes like 1993 SP Football, 1993 Flair Baseball, and 2003 Finest Football under my tree. I also got a few factory sets of early 90's baseball and hockey that hold a lot of sentimental value (and very little resale value.) 

But once in a while Mom would pick out a vintage baseball card from the local card shop, place it an a big acrylic holder, and slap some wrapping paper on it. Just so happened that she picked a pair of 1956 Topps cards - Sandy Koufax and Phil Rizzuto. 

A few years later when PSA piqued my interest, I decided to include both cards in my very first grading order. Still have 'em. And because they were Christmas gifts from the woman who brought me into this world, I don't plan on ever selling 'em.

Sandy's second year card 
Phil's final card; "Scooter" was released in '56.

Then a very bold (and probably very foolish) thought entered my mind - I should start adding more 1956 Topps cards to my collection! And so every time I placed an order at PSA or 4SC or even a major card shop like Dave And Adam's, I'd do my best to add a '56 to the cart.

First came Jerry Coleman. Then Al Rosen. Then Ken Boyer and Wally Post. When I purchased a Nellie Fox PSA 6 I had my third Hall Of Famer. Am I really doing this?

I spotted a Wally Moon PSA 5 on COMC and scooped it up for about $5. I figured EX 5's would be the minimum I'd accept, since that was how my Sandy Koufax graded out. (Besides... an EX 5 of Mickey Mantle sells for anywhere from $500-$1000. That's almost a month's salary! Yeah. Not happening.)

COMC had some decent ungraded* 56's to pick through, and an eBay seller I follow named Battlefield Vintage always has a ton of 1950's stuff in stock. I bought a handful from each source and sent them into PSA when I renewed my membership earlier this year. When the cards were graded and shipped to me I learned some things:

  • I really enjoy having cards graded by PSA
  • Battlefield's eBay listing are about two grades lower than advertised (for example, cards listed as NEAR MINT-MINT often came back as EX-MT 6, not NEAR MINT 8)
  • COMC's ungraded cards yielded a lot more bang for the buck than Battlefield.

[*I prefer the term "ungraded"; "raw" sounds icky to me]

I now have 27 PSA-graded 1956 Topps cards, with a few more in transit to PSA. By the end of September I'll have one-tenth of the 340-card set in EX 5 or better. It's getting harder to convince myself that I'm not collecting the 1956 Topps baseball set. 

I just hope I'm alive long enough to finish it.


Wednesday, August 24, 2016

Good riddance, Railey!

Shortly before Christmas 2014 I had set aside a few hundred dollars for Bowman Chrome Draft boxes and singles. I placed an order at Dave and Adam's as my own personal Christmas present, but I didn't get any "hits" that I can remember. And so I searched eBay for some high-end singles. 

I spotted a 1 of 1 Superfractor of Diamondbacks 3rd-round pick Matt Railey. I had never owned a Superfractor before (they're quite expensive, you know) and though I didn't know much about Matt Railey I at least knew how to spell his last name:

2014 Bowman Chrome Draft CDP95 MATT RILEY Superfractor #1/1 Real

I thought I could take advantage of the seller's misspelled listing and save a few bucks. So I bought the Riley... er, Railey for $125.50.
front side. nice card, eh?
back side. yep, it's a real 1 of 1.

I knew this was a big gamble, despite his relatively high draft position. Railey was not on any top 100 prospect list, or even Arizona's top 10. At the time I purchased this card, Baseball America ranked Railey the 28th best prospect in the D-Backs system. 

Then guess what happened?

You'll never guess what happened.

Railey got suspended for using PEDs. That wiped out nearly all of his first "full" season of rookie ball. I immediately tried to sell my Superfractor for $100 on Check Out My Cards and eBay. No takers. 

He started this season in low class-A and was soon promoted to full-season class A. That was encouraging, right?


Railey batted .136 in A-ball with zero extra-base hits in 59 at-bats. The D-backs released him earlier this month.

As any prospect collector will tell you, once a player is released (or deceased) his cards are virtually worthless. I decided to re-list the Railey on eBay without a Buy It Now Price. 

I let it go in auction for... $17.74. 

Yep, lost over a hundred bucks on this kid. And that is why I'm getting out of the prospecting game...


Tuesday, August 23, 2016


Red Sox rookie Andrew Benintendi made a highlight-reel catch in last night's game against the Tampa Bay Rays.


I've been a die-hard Red Sox fan for over two decades, and I try to hoard as many Sox cards as I can. However the price of high-end prospect cards is so astronomical that I've never owned a Bowman Chrome Autographed card of any significant Red Sox player - not Xander Bogaerts or Mookie Betts or Jackie Bradley or even Blake Swihart. I've had to settle for lower-end base and Chrome parallels like this Blue Sky refractor:

This is the only Benintendi card in my collection. I purchased it on Check Out My Cards for $2.65 before the season started. There is one left at COMC as I write this, and the seller is asking for $15.24. 

I've transitioned away from prospect collecting this year in part because my interest in a player is too often tied to whether or not I own one of their rookie cards (not unlike "owning" a player in fantasy sports). But with Boston players like Benintendi I don't need to own a card of theirs to cheer for them. I'd like to own a high-end rookie card of all the Sox starters, but it's not necessary.

With or without this card, I'm hoping that Benni will join the long list of legendary left fielders in Red Sox history, from Ted Williams to Carl Yastrzemski to Jim Rice to Mike Greenwell (okay, so 'Greenie' was not a legend...but he was MVP runner-up in 1988) to the always entertaining (and often aggravating) Manny Ramirez. It's still very early in his career, but the #7 overall pick in 2015 is already well on his way to stardom. 

Meanwhile Trey Ball, Boston's #7 overall pick in 2013... is still languishing in the minors.

I won't even bother scanning my Ball card.


Sunday, August 21, 2016

Am I really doing this?

I've thought about starting a sports card blog for years. My head would swell with topic ideas and layout designs.. but I never seriously considered blogging specifically about baseball cards. Once in a while I'd write a sports card post on my personal blog The Pedestrian Writer, and while I did get a number of thoughtful comments I always felt like I enjoyed writing them more than my (mostly female) audience enjoyed reading them. 

That's not to say women can't or don't collect sports cards - my wife owns thousands of hockey cards from the early 1990's to the early aughts. But I want to write more posts about all kinds of things - and I want to engage the audience with mutually interesting stories. I started to notice that some bloggers had two blogs, and so the only thing that stopped me from segregating my sports interests from my personal thoughts was time

I never seem to have enough time to do half the things I want (haven't we all felt that way at one time or another?) and if I'm writing posts for two different blogs then I'm spending less time commenting on other blogs. And that would make me feel quite guilty. 

Then I had a thought. 

Instead of writing long-form posts once or twice a week like I do on my personal blog... I will (endeavor to) write very short posts about my sports card and memorabilia collection once a day. Most of them will be under 500 words - perhaps even under 100 words. Some days I'll post about my latest addition to my collection, or my favorite sports card websites, or my experiences buying and selling certain cards. I'll be sure to share updates on player and set collections and, when I don't have anything new to report, I'll pull out a random card from my collection and share some (hopefully) interesting thoughts about the card. Perhaps I'll even include a top ten list once in a while. 

I welcome your feedback on anything you read here or on my other blog. Happy collecting!