Earlier this month, the Baseball Hall of Fame announced ten nominees for the first-ever "Today's Game Era" ballot.
I'm a Hall of Fame junkie, specifically sports Halls of Fame. I'm fascinated by who is elected, who is considered, and how each Hall of Fame has their own criteria and selection process. None of the Halls of Fame get everything exactly right; if they did there'd be nothing to debate. Baseball comes the closest, its eligibility requirements and voting process are the simplest and most transparent. The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame is the most confusing to me - which is why I seek a better understanding of the criteria.
I've been to both halls, having visited Cooperstown in 1991 and 1999 and Cleveland in 2004. (You can read my opinions about the Rock and Roll Hall - and this year's nominees - on my personal blog.)
The "Today's Game Era" is one of four veterans' committees designed to re-evaluate deserving candidates that 10-15 years' worth of BBWAA elections may have missed. In my own research (partially inspired by this article from MLB Network's Brian Kenny) I have identified at least 15 baseball players whose lifetime statistics compare favorably to players that have been inducted - so there is definitely a need for such oversight.
That said, the ten names on the ballot aren't exactly glaring omissions. There are only six players among the ten candidates, and the only one I'd strongly consider is a non-player:
- Harold Baines
- Albert Belle
- Will Clark
- Orel Hershiser
- Davey Johnson (as manager)
- Mark McGwire
- Lou Piniella (as manager)
- John Schuerholz
- Bud Selig
- George Steinbrenner
I feel a little sick to my stomach in saying this, but Steinbrenner is the candidate I'd vote for. I don't see any of these men getting 75% of the vote - Selig and Steinbrenner were both polarizing figures (The Boss was even banned for life at one point) and McGwire's well-documented PED use makes his induction even less likely.
While scrolling through baseball-reference.com for the top players of all-time who are not in the Hall Of Fame, I followed a four-tier system based on the career WAR totals sorted by position. I wont bore you with the specifics, but basically the top tier legends were Bonds, Clemens, and Pete Rose (whose lifetime ban is actually a lifetime ban - unlike Mr. Steinbrenner.)
Tier two consisted of players whose WAR totals were higher than the average of all Hall of Famers at his position. This included recent players you know such as Mike Mussina, Curt Schilling, Ted Simmons, Jeff Bagwell, Palmeiro, Lou Whitaker, Bobby Grich, Alan Trammell, Tim Raines, and Edgar Martinez - as well as some other worthy candidates whose names you may not know - such as Jim McCormick, Bill Dahlen, Jack Glasscock, Sherry Magee, and Bob Johnson.
The players listed in bold are still eligible for enshrinement and will appear on the 2017 BBWAA Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot. (Here's the complete list of 36 eligible players.) This year's BBWAA ballot is a bit difficult to predict; the first year-eligible candidates include:
- Manny Ramirez (known PED user)
- Ivan Rodriguez (suspected PED user)
- Vladimir Guerrero
- Jorge Posada
- Magglio Ordonez
- J. D. Drew
- Javier Vazquez
- Jason Varitek
Many baseball fans and experts (including Brian Kenny) complain that the BBWAA is only allowed to vote for a maximum of ten candidates - as opposed to however many the voter feels is deserving. This could be a problem if you are considering players with PED stink on them or if all of the top non-Hall of Famers could retain eligibility forever - as is the case with the Rock and Roll Hall.
Looking at the 2017 ballot, I don't see ten Hall of Fame players who aren't suspected of using steroids. My ballot would not include Bonds, Clemens, Ramirez, or Sosa - and I would have to think long and hard about Pudge Rodriguez.
Here are the eight players I would vote for:
- Jeff Bagwell
- Tim Raines
- Trevor Hoffman
- Vladimir Guerrero
- Mike Mussina
- Curt Schilling
- Edgar Martinez
- Larry Walker
Which players would you consider worthy of the Baseball Hall Of Fame? Do you think suspected (or confirmed) PED users should be disqualified? Am I overlooking a player you would vote for? Let me know in comments!