Sunday, March 21, 2021

The Immaculate Collection

Here's something I've wanted to do for a while. About a year and a half ago I had a tab at the top of this blog documenting all my purchases of Panini Immaculate cards. It's in need of an update as I've added a few since the last count. The goal was to acquire as many of these cards as possible for less than the cost of an actual box of Immaculate -- which now sells for ... 

Oh holy sh*t. In my original post I was going off the $500-600 price point for a six-card box. I'd made an offer on an older box of immaculate at $400 and it was declined. So... that's as close as I'll ever come to buying a box of this stuff. Since I could theoretically buy hundreds of singles for less than $2,000 I think I'll leave them all here and discontinue the project (it's not like I'm going back to COMC any time soon.)

Scherzer and Barnes are the only two Immaculate singles I've received from bloggers (Dennis and Gavin respectively).

Here's the total breakdown for baseball:

yearsettypenameSN #dcostacquired from
2014Immaculate Swatches PatchrelicMax Scherzer49$0.00Dennis (TMV)
2015Shadowbox Signatures GoldautoMatt Barnes23$0.00Gavin (BCB)
2015Shadowbox SignaturesautoJosh Harrison99$2.25COMC
2017Immaculate SwatchesrelicTommy Henrich99$2.97Beckett Market
2017Immaculate CollectionbaseBuster Posey99$2.05COMC
2018Immaculate CollectionbaseJoe Jackson99$1.52COMC
2018Immaculate Legends BatrelicPaul Waner25$5.25COMC

total for baseball (7)

I flipped this Paul Waner relic on COMC for $10.13 before I'd officially begun hoarding Immaculate cards.

If Panini had an MLB license I'd have a lot more of these. Probably 25 or so, going by my totals in two other sports.

Here's the total breakdown for basketball:

2012-13Immaculate QuadsrelicBrooklyn Nets50$2.50COMC
2014-15Immaculate CollectionbaseLarry Bird99$2.88COMC
2014-15Immaculate CollectionbaseKyle Lowry99$1.15COMC
2014-15Immaculate StandardrelicGoran Dragic50$2.40COMC
2014-15Immaculate StandardrelicGary Harris75$2.02COMC
2014-15Immaculate StandardrelicBrook Lopez75$1.35COMC
2014-15Shadowbox SignaturesautoTom Chambers49$3.97COMC
2014-15Shadowbox Signatures GoldautoAlex English10$9.60COMC
2015-16Immaculate CollectionbaseGordon Hayward99$1.00COMC
2015-16Immaculate CollectionbaseDirk Nowitzki99$1.65COMC
2015-16Immaculate Coll. BronzeparallelTim Duncan49$3.25COMC
2015-16Immaculate Coll. BronzeparallelNerlens Noel99$0.78COMC
2015-16Immaculate Dual MemorabiliarelicDeMarre Carroll25$1.75COMC
2015-16Immaculate Memorabilia RedrelicAl Jefferson25$1.67COMC
2015-16Immaculate StandardrelicRay Allen75$4.90COMC
2015-16Immaculate StandardrelicSerge Ibaka75$1.15COMC
2015-16Shadowbox SignaturesautoDavid Thompson99$4.30COMC
2016-17Heralded SignaturesautoKenny Anderson99$6.00card show
2016-17Heralded SignaturesautoDan Majerle99$6.00card show
2016-17Historical SignifiganceautoRick Barry99$12.00card show
2017-18Immaculate Swatches GoldrelicXavier McDaniel10$7.30COMC
2018-19Marks of GreatnessautoHorace Grant99$15.00card show
2018-19Modern Marks GoldautoKevin Love10$15.00card show
2018-19 Immaculate SwatchesrelicChristian Laettner99$1.62COMC

total basketball (24)

Outside of COMC these singles get more expensive. I don't mind paying a premium at a card show though.


Four Immaculate basketball cards I purchased are no longer in my collection. I flipped three of them on COMC, earning a grand total of $1.44 in profit (I should have just kept the cards) and I sent one to Kerry.

My favorite subset/insert set under the Immaculate brand are the acetate relics from 2015 football. They're numbered to each player's uniform number, which makes certain players (such as Brett Favre) very tough to obtain.

Here's the total breakdown for football:

2015Immaculate CollectionbaseLen Dawson99$0.95COMC
2015Immaculate CollectionbaseMarshall Faulk99$0.95COMC
2015Immaculate CollectionbaseAdrian Peterson99$1.75COMC
2015Immaculate CollectionbaseRoddy White99$0.88COMC
2015Immaculate CollectionbaseLaDanian Tomlinson99$1.22COMC
2015Immaculate Collection GoldparallelJulio Jones25$1.00COMC
2015Immaculate Collection GoldparallelMichael Strahan25$1.45COMC
2015Immaculate NumbersrelicTim Brown81$5.00COMC
2015Immaculate NumbersrelicEric Dickerson29$14.27COMC
2015Immaculate NumbersrelicT. Y. Hilton13$4.52COMC
2015Immaculate NumbersrelicSteve Largent80$8.75COMC
2015Immaculate NumbersrelicJordy Nelson87$16.25COMC
2015Immaculate NumbersrelicAdrian Peterson28$22.99Beckett Market
2015Immaculate NumbersrelicRoddy White84$1.95COMC
2015Immaculate NumbersrelicLaDanian Tomlinson21$24.00eBay
2017Immaculate CollectionbaseEric Dickerson99$1.62COMC
2017Immaculate CollectionbaseJohn Elway99$1.25COMC
2017Immaculate CollectionbaseBrett Favre99$2.20COMC
2017Immaculate PatchesrelicJordan Reed8$8.45COMC
2018Immaculate CollectionbaseDavante Adams99$1.12COMC
2018Immaculate CollectionbaseDrew Brees99$1.65COMC
2018Immaculate CollectionbaseLeonard Fournette99$0.95COMC
2018Immaculate CollectionbasePeyton Manning99$2.00COMC
2018Immaculate NumbersrelicTerrell Suggs55$2.50COMC
2019Immaculate Players GU/AUMorten Andersen99$26.66eBay

total for football (25)

I flipped one football card on COMC: a Steve Largent gold parallel which earned another $1.34 in profit. 
Shoulda brought this one home, too.

Including cards I've flipped for a tiny profit on COMC (and the one card I sent to Kerry) I have spent a total of $290.36 on 60 Immaculate singles. There aren't any "sick hits" in my stack but I think it's a better value than a 6-card box - even at pre-Covid pries:

Thanks for reading!



  1. Wow, interesting project. I think my faves are the Scherzer and Heinrich relics, the Bird, Dirk and Duncan base/parallels, McDaniel relic, Rick Barry Auto, Peterson relic and Morten Anderson relic. But they are all pretty sweet! I would never buy a box of these, so your method is definitely awesome!

  2. I love finding the Baseball sitting in dollar boxes (my problem is that I typically skip those boxes). I need to at least flip through thtem.

  3. The fact that someone would willingly drop $2k on a box of sports cards still boggles my mind.

  4. Have you tried looking on Sportlots for these? Looking at your basketball autos, I'd say you've been able to acquire some "hits". Love that Larry Legend btw :)

  5. Makes me not want to buy an unopened box of any cards, really. I love opening packs, but with a high end product, it makes a ton of sense to let someone else break the boxes and just go after singles that I actually want!
    Some fantastic acquisitions here! Of the whole lot I'd say the Xavier McDaniel has the best eye appeal.

  6. Cool project. I'm super jealous of the Waner and Largent relic cards. Great prices.

  7. This is one of those moments where I may have under-appreciated the set/design when seeing them here and there, one or a few at a time, but seeing your entire collection mapped out like this they are IMPRESSIVE. Congrats on this collection, you should be proud of these for sure!